From Tui Shou to Takedown - Reflections on Rulesets and Taijiquan Skill Development

This is the second of two articles about my experiences in a tui shou (pushing hands) competition I entered in London in June 2022. Competing in two very different bouts offered deep insights into successfully applying the Taijiquan shen fa (body method): rooting, peng jin, and ting jin under pressure. More importantly, the experience highlighted a fundamental insight: The controlled environment of Taijiquan push hands is not merely an isolated game, but a crucial laboratory for developing skills that can then be adapted to the chaos of MMA, so long as one understands how dramatically the rules, intentions, and tactical demands shift outside the push-hands format.

1. The Paradox of Context: Playing the Same Game

​As a Taijiquan practitioner, I found it significantly easier to execute a throw within the pushing hands rule set than I have in an MMA context. This isn’t surprising. Martial arts are often most effective against practitioners of the same or similar arts because both participants are essentially “playing the same game.” It is in cross-training or cross-style encounters that one encounters unfamiliar actions and reactions, which make techniques harder to apply.

​However, this limitation is also a critical part of the learning process. For example, a student learning Judo may initially struggle to secure throws against a Wrestling specialist. That doesn't mean the process of skill development is flawed or should be abandoned. Once they've honed their timing and mechanics against other judoka, they possess the foundation needed to being applying those skills against grapplers from different backgrounds. The same principle applies to Taijiquan.

​2. Comparing Constraints: How Rules Shape Engagement

​The differences in rule structure are significant because they fundamentally change the opponent’s strategic motivation.

​In pushing hands, victory comes either by pushing the opponent out of bounds or throwing them to the floor, and attacking the legs with the arms is not allowed. This framework incentivizes the opponent to push into you, generating the very tension and commitment (or stiffness) that a Taijiquan practitioner is trained to exploit for leverage, trips, and throws.

​In stark contrast, MMA often presents one of two situations that negate this dynamic:

1. ​The Anti-Grappler: The opponent avoids the clinch entirely, playing an "anti-wrestling" game by constantly maintaining distance, framing, pushing away, and resetting. Without genuine engagement, it’s impossible to leverage their weight or stiffness.

   
   

2. The Grappler: If the opponent is a dedicated grappler and wants to close the distance, they are incentivized to preemptively attack the low line, the legs, to bring the fight to the ground. This method is often easier and more efficient than the upper-body takedowns, trips, and throws used in Taijiquan. As a result, prolonged, structure-testing clinch exchanges like those in pushing hands rarely occur for any length of time in open space in MMA.

3. From Refinement to Reality: The Practical Pathway to Application

The most valuable insight for me was recognising that there is a real pathway for applying Taijiquan’s trips, sweeps, and throws in an MMA context. The key is not to jump straight into chaotic clinching, but to first build and refine the mechanics inside Taijiquan’s controlled framework, where patterns, timing, and angles can actually be repeated and corrected. This is the bridge between latent capacity and functional skill. Only after these skills are stable do you take them into progressively more open clinch environments. It's the solid foundation from the first-phase that makes the methods fast, intuitive, and pressure-ready, so that in live, adaptive encounters they actually work.

However, this insight also highlights my current practical dilemma. Without access to other Taijiquan practitioners, I cannot accumulate the training volume required within that controlled framework where the functional skills are actually built. Instead, I’m am left attempting to develop these advanced body skills directly in a highly unconstrained environment, making the learning curve slow, inconsistent, and often frustrating. The competition reinforced this for me: the controlled “laboratory” of push hands isn’t a luxury or an optional extra, but an essential step in developing the Taijiquan body method for broader combat application.

Follow My Writing